Cartagena vs Catania

Colombia · Latin America

Cartagena

is Getsemaní
Italy · Europe

Catania

is San Berillo

Both neighborhoods turned crumbling walls into canvases, but they're chasing different highs. Getsemaní is warmer and busier: salsa from open doorways, dominoes in Plaza de la Trinidad, murals stacked across a dozen-plus streets, all of it loud past midnight. San Berillo is smaller and stranger, just four surviving streets carrying the weight of its red-light past, now half community co-op and half wine bar with a queer bookshop next to a painted saint. Cartagena gives you heat, music, and crowds. Catania gives you something more political and more fragile, where the history is recent enough to still feel raw on the sidewalk.

The Brooklyn of

Cartagena is Getsemaní.

Street art covers every wall on Callejón Angosto. Salsa pours out of open doorways past midnight. Old guys play dominoes in Plaza de la Trinidad while tourists photograph murals ten feet away. Getsemaní is louder, cheaper, and more real than the walled city next door, and it doesn't care if you noticed.

Since the first International Festival of Urban Art in 2013, murals have spread across more than a dozen streets in Getsemaní, with the local CapTagEna Collective alone counting 20+ artists who have shaped the neighborhood's walls.
The Brooklyn of

Catania is San Berillo.

San Berillo was Catania's red-light district until recently. Now the crumbling palazzi house community co-ops, street art, and wine bars where locals spill onto broken sidewalks at midnight. It's raw, political, and genuinely interesting. A mural of a saint shares a wall with a queer bookshop.

Since 2010, more than a dozen national and international artists have covered San Berillo's walls as part of the Red Line Distreet project - all packed into a neighborhood of roughly 4 surviving streets.
The numbers

At a glance.

Cartagena Catania
Region Latin America Europe
Country Colombia Italy
Neighborhood Getsemaní San Berillo
Currency COP EUR
Language Spanish Italian
Cost level $$ Moderate $$ Moderate
Best months December to March May, late September, and October
Local time UTC-5 UTC+2
Plug US plug EU plug
Emergency 123 112
Vibe overlap

What they share, and what they don't.

Both

Cartagena only

Catania only

The verdict

It depends on the weekend.

Cartagena Late-night music, street food, and sheer energy spread across more streets than you can cover in one night.

Catania Compact, politically charged reinvention where queer spaces and community co-ops grow out of a recent red-light past.

Common questions

Cartagena or Catania, answered.

Is Cartagena or Catania better for nightlife?
Cartagena wins for sheer volume. Getsemaní pushes salsa out of open doorways past midnight across more streets than you can cover in one night. Catania's San Berillo runs quieter and stranger - just four surviving streets where locals spill onto broken sidewalks outside wine bars at midnight. Go to Getsemaní for loud, crowded energy; go to San Berillo for something smaller and more political.
Is Cartagena or Catania better for LGBTQ travelers?
Catania. San Berillo built its reinvention around queer spaces, with a queer bookshop sharing a wall with a painted saint and community co-ops growing out of its recent red-light past. Getsemaní in Cartagena leans into music, street food, and crowds rather than explicitly queer culture. If you want politically charged, LGBTQ-friendly reinvention, San Berillo is the clear pick.
Which is cooler, Getsemaní or San Berillo?
Depends on what you want. Getsemaní in Cartagena is warmer and busier: murals stacked across a dozen-plus streets, dominoes in the plaza, salsa loud past midnight. San Berillo in Catania is smaller and stranger, four streets carrying the weight of a recent red-light past, now half community co-op and half wine bar. Getsemaní buys you heat and music; San Berillo buys you raw, fragile politics.
If you like this

Try one of these.

The dispatch

Stay in the loop.

New cities, updated guides, and travel tips for the neighborhoods worth visiting. Join the list.