Detroit vs St. Louis

USA · North America

Detroit

is Corktown
USA · North America

St. Louis

is Cherokee Street

Detroit and St. Louis are both Rust Belt cities that took a beating and never fully left. But they recovered differently. Detroit has the money coming back in now - Ford's billion-dollar train station, the cocktail bars on Michigan Avenue, the sense that something is being rebuilt. St. Louis never really got that wave. Cherokee Street doesn't care. It's cheaper, messier, and more honest about what it is. Pick Detroit if you want to watch a city find itself. Pick St. Louis if you want a city that stopped looking.

The Brooklyn of

Detroit is Corktown.

Corktown is Detroit's oldest surviving neighborhood and it wears that history without being precious about it. Michigan Avenue is the spine, lined with converted brick buildings housing coffee roasters, cocktail bars, and some of the best food in the city. The recently restored Michigan Central Station looms like a cathedral at the western end. It's the rare place where old Detroit and new Detroit actually coexist without awkwardness.

Ford's nearly $1 billion restoration of Michigan Central Station anchors a 30-acre campus, while Michigan Avenue now hosts 20+ independent bars and restaurants within roughly a mile.
The Brooklyn of

St. Louis is Cherokee Street.

Cherokee Street is where St. Louis stops trying to impress anyone and just lives. Mexican groceries sit next to record shops and cocktail bars. Saturday afternoons, the sidewalks fill up with people who actually live here, not tourists. It's cheap, it's real, and the tacos are better than anything downtown.

Cherokee Street packs over 180 independent businesses into less than half a mile, including six blocks of antique shops that still price like it's 2009.
The numbers

At a glance.

Detroit St. Louis
Region North America North America
Country USA USA
Neighborhood Corktown Cherokee Street
Currency USD USD
Language English English
Cost level $$ Moderate $$ Moderate
Best months September, plus June and early July May, June, September, and October
Local time UTC-4 UTC-5
Plug US plug US plug
Emergency 911 911
Vibe overlap

What they share, and what they don't.

Both

Detroit only

St. Louis only

The verdict

It depends on the weekend.

Detroit wins for architecture, craft cocktails, and the energy of a city mid-reinvention.

St. Louis wins for cheap eats, record shops, and a neighborhood that actually belongs to its residents.

Read Detroit in full → Read St. Louis in full →
Common questions

Detroit or St. Louis, answered.

Is Detroit or St. Louis better for street food?
St. Louis, no contest. Cherokee Street runs on Mexican groceries and taco counters that beat anything downtown, and the food belongs to the people who live there. Detroit's Corktown leans toward craft cocktails and fine dining along Michigan Avenue. Go to Detroit to eat well at a table; go to St. Louis to eat cheap on the sidewalk.
Is St. Louis better for record shopping than Detroit?
Yes. Cherokee Street stacks record shops next to vintage stores and live-music spots, the kind of place built for digging through crates on a Saturday afternoon. Detroit's Corktown leans toward coffee roasters, craft beer, and cocktail bars instead. If vinyl and live music are the trip, St. Louis is the clear pick.
Which is cooler, Corktown or Cherokee Street?
Depends what cool means to you. Corktown is Detroit's oldest neighborhood mid-reinvention, where restored brick buildings and a rebuilt train station signal money coming back. Cherokee Street stopped trying to impress anyone - cheaper, messier, and run by its residents, not tourists. Pick Corktown to watch a city rebuild. Pick Cherokee Street for somewhere that already feels lived-in and real.
If you like this

Try one of these.

Baltimore vs Detroit

North America

Chicago vs Detroit

North America

Detroit vs Leipzig

North America · Europe
The dispatch

Stay in the loop.

New cities, updated guides, and travel tips for the neighborhoods worth visiting. Join the list.