Philadelphia vs Richmond

USA · North America

Philadelphia

is Fishtown
USA · North America

Richmond

is Jackson Ward

Philadelphia and Richmond both have the same working-class bones and the same chip on the shoulder about not being New York. But they wear it differently. Philly is bigger, louder, and Fishtown's Frankford Avenue hits harder than almost any dining strip on the East Coast. Richmond is smaller and slower, and Jackson Ward carries a history that Philly's neighborhoods can't touch. Go to Philly when you want to eat yourself into the ground. Go to Richmond when you want to feel a city that actually remembers who it is.

The Brooklyn of

Philadelphia is Fishtown.

Fishtown is a former working-class neighborhood where the old Irish bars never left but the natural wine shops moved in next door. Everything runs along Frankford Avenue, a long, walkable strip where you'll pass a Lebanese restaurant that looks like a palace, a record shop, and three coffee roasters before lunch. It still feels like Philly here. People are loud and the food is serious.

Frankford Avenue packs more than 25 independent restaurants and bars into a 2-mile stretch through Fishtown alone.
The Brooklyn of

Richmond is Jackson Ward.

Jackson Ward was the Harlem of the South long before anyone started making comparisons to Brooklyn. The historic Black business district along 2nd Street still pulses with soul food joints, Ethiopian coffee, and weekend crowds that spill onto Broad Street. Iron-laced porches line every block.

The Mending Walls project spans 16 murals created by 30 local artists across a 42-square-block neighborhood that once housed over 100 Black-owned businesses.
The numbers

At a glance.

Philadelphia Richmond
Region North America North America
Country USA USA
Neighborhood Fishtown Jackson Ward
Currency USD USD
Language English English
Cost level $$$ Moderate to expensive $$$ Moderate to expensive
Best months May to June and September to October October, then April and May
Local time UTC-4 UTC-4
Plug US plug US plug
Emergency 911 911
Vibe overlap

What they share, and what they don't.

Both

Philadelphia only

Richmond only

The verdict

It depends on the weekend.

Philadelphia Philadelphia wins on sheer restaurant firepower - Kalaya alone is worth the flight.

Richmond Richmond wins on history and soul - Jackson Ward is unlike anywhere else in the South.

Common questions

Philadelphia or Richmond, answered.

Is Philadelphia or Richmond better for restaurants?
Philadelphia. Fishtown's Frankford Avenue is one of the harder-hitting dining strips on the East Coast, and Philly wins on sheer restaurant firepower. Richmond's Jackson Ward holds its own with soul food joints and Ethiopian coffee along 2nd Street, but if you want to eat yourself into the ground, Philadelphia is the stronger pick.
Is Philadelphia or Richmond better for history?
Richmond. Jackson Ward was the Harlem of the South, a historic Black business district that still pulses along 2nd Street, with iron-laced porches lining every block. Philadelphia's Fishtown has working-class bones and old Irish bars, but it carries nothing close to Jackson Ward's depth. Go to Richmond to feel a city that remembers who it is.
Which is cooler, Fishtown or Jackson Ward?
Depends on what you want. Fishtown is louder and bigger, with natural wine shops next to old Irish bars and three coffee roasters before lunch along Frankford Avenue. Jackson Ward is slower and deeper, built on street art, soul food, and architecture worth the walk. Pick Fishtown to eat and drink hard. Pick Jackson Ward for history and soul.
If you like this

Try one of these.

The dispatch

Stay in the loop.

New cities, updated guides, and travel tips for the neighborhoods worth visiting. Join the list.